Verdurin logo
Home » Events » After Therapy

After Therapy

Suffering in the age of Big Mental Health

Black and white photo of four nurses in vintage hospital uniforms inside a historic medical facility.

Nurses at Saxondale mental hospital, Nottingham/Wellcome Collection


14 November 2026  2:00pm  – 6:00pm

Event location: Verdurin

The comedian Johnny Carson quipped that in Hollywood, if you didn’t have a shrink, everyone thought you were crazy. The joke has spread beyond Tinseltown. ‘Mental health’ content proliferates, ads for online therapy platforms are ubiquitous, and language once confined to the consulting room appears in corporate strategy documents. Welcome to the age of Big Mental Health.

The origins of the therapeutic turn lie in the anti-psychiatry and psychiatric survivor movements of the 1960s. These allied forces sought liberation: from stigma, pathologization, and the coercive practices of institutional psychiatry, whose high priests wield power through the complex nomenclature of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM).

In the rapidly innovating healthcare systems, anti-psychiatry was a dead end, its critique overtaken by developments in psychopharmacology, which reduced the use of some more obviously injurious applications of physical restraint and entrenched the bio-medical model of the mind. The DSM’s empire has waxed ever larger. 

But the activism of the ’60s did give rise to new ways of conceptualizing mental distress. The efforts to ‘normalize’ its manifestations have replaced the old discourse of madness with a new discourse centred around the amoeba idea of ‘mental health’ and shaped by the forces of managerialism and identitarianism. 

One paradoxical effect of this is that swathes of commonplace emotional experience are now pathologized. Another that the experience of severe mental distress has again become marginalized. A third is that the diagnostic labels, that previous generations of activists rejected are now prized, yet evacuated of meaning. 

Is there space for genuine illness in ‘mental health’ discourse? Can we still rely on Freud’s distinction between “neurotic despair” and ordinary human misery? Do we need more or less therapy, and to what private, social, or political end? 

Symposium programme

Writer James Mumford will argue that one major reason we find ourselves needing therapy is that we have lost the courage of our convictions. We have become estranged from the resources (tradition, custom, faith) that have historically satisfied our yearning for truth, hope and healing. So when therapy insists it is up to us to create meaning in a vacuum, it can only deepen our despair. If nihilism is what brought us to our knees, and into therapy, why should another dose of it from therapy help us find our feet again?

Sociologist Ashley Frawley will focus on a paradox in cultural treatments of “mental health”: serious mental illness is increasingly depathologised, while the medicalisation of everyday life continues apace. As the language of emancipatory politics has become institutionalised, the outsider has come to be seen as an already liberated subject, and the “normal” as the people who keep society’s oppressive norms going. As material explanations of social problems fall away, people’s everyday behaviour comes under ever closer scrutiny.

Psychotherapist and writer Mark Vernon will argue that the psychodynamic psychotherapies are necessary but not sufficient, because they rest on too small an idea of interiority, one conceived only in relation to the human individual. Psychotherapy grew out of metaphysical agnosticism, if not atheism, and so can itself be thought of as incomplete. Mark will look back to William Blake, who wrote before psychology existed, and ask what his work suggests about how therapy might be extended.

Show more +

After Therapy is organised with Emma Bielecki and Nina Power.


  • Ashley Frawley

    Ashley Frawley is the author of Semiotics of Happiness and Significant Emotions.

  • James Mumford

    James Mumford is the author of Vexed, and has written about ethics, literature, and politics for US and British outlets.

  • Mark Vernon

    Mark Vernon is a psychotherapist and writer.


×